top of page

Prison Libraries and the Right to Culture.

Oct 28
9 min read

There is a room that a lot of people never think about. It’s usually situated somewhere in the middle of a building specifically designed to make you forget you’re a person. It has fluorescent light and institutional carpet the colour of resignation. Maybe shelves, if you’re lucky. Real shelves, with real books on them. Not some trolley wheeled around twice a week like a consolation prize. As modest as it sounds, this room has been host to some of the most consequential intellectual journeys in recorded history. Malcolm X reinvented himself in one. Gramsci composed his notebooks in conditions that could be compared to slow suffocation, but the ideas he was reaching for would be shaped by what he was allowed to read. Nelson Mandela studied law. Dostoyevsky went in as a radical and emerged…well, as Dostoyevsky.


Nelson Mandela (1918–2013). This photograph was taken in Washington, D.C., on 4 October 1994 by Kingkongphoto and sourced from Flickr/Wikimedia Commons. It is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic (CC BY-SA 2.0) licence.
Nelson Mandela (1918–2013). This photograph was taken in Washington, D.C., on 4 October 1994 by Kingkongphoto and sourced from Flickr/Wikimedia Commons. It is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic (CC BY-SA 2.0) licence.

The prison library. Even the name has a vague hint of oxymoron about it. As if culture and confinement are fundamentally allergic to each other. But that tension is exactly the point. A library doesn’t exist in a prison by accident, it’s there as a decision. And what happens to it; how it’s staffed and funded, respected and stocked, or gutted and locked on Tuesdays because there’s no guard to supervise, all of that is a political statement. Whether anyone is honest enough to call it one or not.


Most people, if they think about it at all, tend to think of cultural provision in prisons as charity. A goodwill gesture. That society, in all its magnanimity, allows the incarcerated to read. Books get donated, volunteers run workshops. Maybe a retired librarian gives up her Thursday afternoons. Deliberately and consistently, it is framed as largess, as something which can be given and, crucially, taken away.


This is a lie. At the very least, it’s a deep category error, and that distinction matters hugely.


Access to culture; literature, history, to the collected record of human thought, is not a reward for good behaviour. It’s not a privilege extended to a lucky few who have expressed sufficient gratitude for their incarceration. It is a right. And I don’t mean in the wishy-washy, we-all-deserve-nice-things sense, but in the hard, structural sense. When a state imprisons someone, it takes custodial responsibility for that person’s welfare. It takes their liberty. In doing this, it takes on certain obligations. Legal ones, yes, but more basic human ones, and these don’t disappear just because that person did something wrong.


The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners, the Mandela Rules last updated in 2015, are not ambiguous on this. Every prison shall have a library for the use of all categories of prisoners, stocked adequately with recreational and instructional books. The word shall is doing a lot of work there. It isn’t should or ideally would and definitely not whenever budget permits. The international consensus on this point isn’t even slightly ambiguous. But what is ambiguous, varying wildly by jurisdiction, budget cycle, and the political weather, is whether any given state really intends to honour it. 


Let’s get specific, because abstraction is where political cowardice goes to hide.


In Wales and England, the early 2010s saw a wave of cuts to prison library services so systematic, they could only be deliberate. The Ministry of Justice, ruling over a carceral estate already buckling due to chronic overcrowding, decided in their wisdom that library services were basically a discretionary luxury. Local authority library services, historically providing outreach to prisons, found their own budgets cut. The knock-on effect was all too predictable to anyone who cared to look, and invisible for those who preferred not to.


By the mid-2010s, the picture was brutal. Reports from Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons documented, over and over with the weary tone of someone saying the same thing into a void, that library provision was wholly inadequate across huge swathes of the prison estate. Books were outdated and opening hours were restricted. Not because of the policy decisions made by people thinking carefully about rehabilitation, but because no guard was available to open the door. In some prisons, the prisoners could access the library for as little as thirty minutes a week. Thirty minutes. You spend thirty minutes stuck in traffic on the A406 and consider it a normal Tuesday. 


This problem wasn’t unique to Britain. In the United States, where the carceral state works on a scale that still breaks the imagination of most people who haven’t sat with the numbers, the picture is much worse. In Bounds v. Smith (1977), the Supreme Court established that prisoners have a constitutional right to access the courts. In practice, this necessitates access to legal materials. But the interpretation of that right has been slowly narrowed. Something that once was understood to imply meaningful library access has been squeezed into a resentful provision of legal aid programs that, in many facilities, exist in name only. Regular reading materials: history, fiction, poetry, etc, aren’t protected constitutionally in the same way, and so in practice, that means they are optional. And optional, in a system chronically underfunding everything that doesn’t directly service the security function, means absent. 


There is a certain sleight of hand which occurs when governments defend prison service cuts: the make it all about money. The budget didn’t allow it, they’ll say. Efficiencies had to be found, and frontline security can’t be compromised. In isolation, these statements sound reasonable. In context, they are deeply dishonest.


A prison librarian isn’t a luxury item. I want to state that clearly, as the professional has been pretty much written out of the conversation. They have been replaced, where any provision actually exists, by a trolley service which is run by hard-working but overstretched prison guards with no training in information science. Or by volunteers with their heart in the right place, but can’t be held to any consistent standard of provision.


In a custodial setting, a trained librarian does things that don’t show up in a cost-benefit analysis written by some suit-wearing accountant who has never set foot inside a prison. They will find the functionally illiterate man on the wing who has been hiding it for three decades, as shame is a more durable jailer than any wall. Or they’ll find the book that breaks something open in the woman who hasn’t spoken to a counsellor in two years. They will order the legal texts that allow someone to understand what happened to them in court, or what may yet happen with their appeal. In the extraordinary constraints of a controlled environment, they create something that feels like a space apart. Not freedom, exactly, but a room where the gaze of the state is, just for a moment, not directly on you.


If you cut the librarian, you lose more than the service. You lose the advocacy, the intelligence, the professional judgement about what that particular population needs from its collection. And you are left with whatever someone thought to donate, sorted through by whoever had a spare hour and accessible only when a staff member happens to be available. A right has been replaced with the rumour of a gesture.


There is an uncomfortable question that library provision forces us to ask: what do we really think prisons are for?


When asked, most governments will give the answer of rehabilitation. Reintegration to society, and the reduction of reoffending. These words appear in policy documents, ministerial statements and the preambles in sentencing guidelines. In many jurisdictions, they are almost totally disconnected from anything that really happens inside the institutions those governments run.


Properly understood, rehabilitation is not a programme you attend weekly, or a box ticked on a risk assessment form. It’s a process, non-linear, slow, and incredibly personal, through which a person rebuilds their relationship with themselves and the society they will eventually return to. The research on this is not exactly thin on the ground. It’s extensive and consistent: education in prison reduces reoffending. Reading improves cognitive function, empathy, and emotional regulation. Access to culture, stories of other lives and times, and other ways of being human, helps expand the moral and imaginative vocabulary available to a person trying to work out who they are and who they might become.


This isn’t speculation. It’s well documented and yet systematically ignored. 


A government cutting library provisions is not making a neutral administrative decision. They are expressing a philosophy, and one they’d rather not say out loud, because if they did it would sound like this: We do not believe these people are going to change and we are not prepared to invest in the possibility that they might. Or alternatively, and I think this is more accurate: Our constituents are not rewarded for caring about this, so we won’t care about it either.


There is a word for that attitude believing certain types of people, by virtue of their failures, their poverty, crimes, or bad decisions in a world built to produce bad decisions, forfeit their claim to be treated as totally human. It’s not a popular word, and tends to make people defensive. But it is accurate. 


No essay about prison libraries can avoid the question of censorship, as that is where the political nature of cultural provision becomes completely undeniable. 


In the United States, the list of books banned from multiple state prison systems reads like a syllabus for understanding that country’s discomfort with itself. Michelle Alexander’s The New Jim Crow, a rigorous sociological analysis on mass incarceration of African-American males was banned and restricted in various facilities. Books on prisoner rights, critical race theory, books that explained to incarcerated people the political and legal machinery that put them where they are, in various jurisdictions they have been deemed a threat to facility security.


Sit with that for a moment. A book which explains how the criminal justice system works is a threat to the security of a building filled with people processed by the criminal justice system. 


What’s being protected here isn’t safety. What is being protected is ignorance. And specifically, the ignorance of the governed. Inside a prison, that category is unusually literal. If a prisoner understands their rights, they can exercise them. They can challenge conditions, organise, or file complaints. In the custodial context, knowledge is not just empowering. From the perspective of an institution depending on asymmetric power, it’s actively destabilising.


The banned book list isn’t an aberration. Rather it’s the logical conclusion of a system which frames cultural provision as a charitable gesture instead of a right. If you’re giving something as a gift, you can choose what to give. If you decide the gift of that particular book may cause inconvenience, you just don’t give it. The language of charity then enables the logic of censorship.


Briefly, let’s follow the money, as this is always, always where the argument ends up.


The cost of stocking adequately and staffing a prison library, in the total cost of incarceration, is negligible. The UK spends somewhere in the region of £60,000 per prisoner per year. Depending on which state, the United States spends between $25,000 and $80,000.


Put against those figures, the cost of professional library provision, with books, a librarian and sensible opening hours, is rounding-error money. It isn’t the budget that constrains this, it’s the will.


And that investments return, measured in the only metric that should matter to a government serious about rehabilitation and reduced reoffending, is positive and measurable. Studies consistently show that prisoners who engage with education and reading programmes are much less likely to return to custody. The RAND Corporation, not well known for its sentimentality, published a landmark meta-analysis in 2013 which found that inmates who participated in educational programs were 43% less likely to reoffend. Forty-three percent. Were a government to introduce a policy in any other area of public life that reduced the relevant failure rate by 43%, there would be a huge press conference. There would be a legacy.


But the library doesn’t have a constituency. The prisoner, when convicted and stripped of the vote in most of the jurisdictions we’re discussing, can’t punish the politician who defunds their shelf. The tabloid newspaper running stories about soft-touch justice has much more political weight than the inspectors report gathering dust on some civil servant’s shelf. 


Let’s go back to that room. The one with the fluorescent light and institutional carpet. With the shelves. 


Whenever that room is well-funded, staffed with professionals and filled with books which treat its users as intelligent people capable of growth; when it’s opened for reasonable hours and you don’t have to beg an officer to unlock the door, that room is making a statement. Not a loud one, not a manifesto or banner. Just a durable, quiet, radical statement that the people in that building are still people. Their minds are still active. And that the state, for all that it’s removed their freedom, has not decided to remove their humanity also. 


If that room is gutted, being locked on Tuesdays and Thursdays, stocked with 2004’s donations and staffed by nobody because the budget doesn’t allow it, that’s also making a statement. It’s louder in its silence. It says: We did the accounts, and you don’t make the cut. It says: We may say rehabilitation, but we mean warehousing. And perhaps most accurately: That door will open in three to five years, depending on your licence conditions, and whatever you are when it does, you were that when you came in, and that’s your problem. Not ours. 


That is the political choice. Not the absence of a choice, it’s never that. A choice. Made in budget meetings and committee rooms and ministerial offices by people who know exactly what they’re doing and prefer not to say it plainly. 


The prison library isn’t just a reading room. It’s a referendum on what society believes about human beings; their capacity for change and their right to exist in the imagination of the state as more than just a problem to be managed. Every jurisdiction that guts it has cast its vote.


It’s worth knowing which way yours went.

Comments


bottom of page