Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning, The Film That Came Too Late:
As both film lover and self-proclaimed techno-critique, Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning seemed to come at the perfect time. In headlines, the average child is spending the equivalent of 53 school days on social media. In everyday life, we can all modestly admit that doomscrolling serves us breakfast, lunch and dinner.
In 2008, Nicholas Carr published an article in The Atlantic in 2008 titled “Is Google Making Us Stupid”. He wrote:
“Over the past few years I’ve had an uncomfortable sense that someone, or something, has been tinkering with my brain, remapping the neural circuitry, reprogramming the memory”.
Carr’s hypothesis came just four years after Facebook’s initial release. Two years later, David Fincher released The Social Network, a film hailed by critics for its sharp, cynical portrait of modern ambition. In Sorkin’s screenplay, Zuckerberg’s character evolves into something resembling a real-life Dr. No; the cold, calculating Bond villain for the digital age. The resemblance to Meta’s real-world leadership is difficult to ignore.
I did my homework. The Social Reckoning draws on the reporting behind The Wall Street Journal’s “The Facebook Files”, a landmark investigative series that brought internal company documents and whistleblower Frances Haugen’s revelations into public view. The reporting earned journalist Jeff Horwitz a Pulitzer Prize, while Haugen testified before Congress and appeared on the cover of TIME’s 100 most influential people issue.

Looking retrospectively, what made Fincher’s film so successful was its simplicity. Facebook is shown to be aware of the addictive potential of its platform, but Zuckerberg remains a young entrepreneur whose moral ambiguity can still be mistaken for youthful ambition. His behaviour though troubling, has room to be rationalised. Perhaps this is what it takes to succeed in big business.
Sorkin offers a more damning portrait. His Zuckerberg is no less aware of the harm his company causes, but the decade-plus separation between the two films left us with too much evidence to let that knowledge pass unchallenged.
I should make something clear: The Social Reckoning is not a “bad” film. I enjoyed it. My parents, both chronically offline, left the cinema unnerved. My mum noted the “odd” feeling in her gut upon leaving. She has no social media account knowing that, if she were to create one, she would like the rest of us, struggle to stay away. For her, the film humanised and actualised an enormous problem, offering a gateway into understanding how technology can shape and corrupt behaviour.
That is precisely why my review chooses a critical tone. If the film can introduce these dangers to someone largely untouched by social media, what does it offer those of us already living with them?
For the everyday use, very little is shocking or revealing. It is fascinating to see the behind-the-scenes of an infamous piece of journalism, but I left the cinema without feeling that I had learnt anything new. I use social media every day. I would love to write this review as a glorified grass-toucher, but I check my phone routinely when I wake up and before I go to sleep. I am not an outsider observing this problem. I am part of it.
Too much to say & too little time.
One of the film’s central weaknesses lies in its premise. It attempts to tell a sweeping story about Facebook, drawing together scandals and controversies from roughly 2019 to 2021, including;
The platform’s alleged role in radicalisation, with its recommendation systems potentially directing users toward extremist communities.
Evidence that Instagram can worsen body-image concerns and mental-health struggles among teenage girls.
The ways Facebook and Instagram have transformed bullying and harassment among young people.
The prioritisation of user-engagement over safety by design.
Facebook’s influence over political discourse, including its approach to misinformation, free speech and political advertising.
Each issue is formidable enough to sustain a storyline of its own. Yet, within a runtime of 112 minutes, they compete for attention rather than develop into a coherent argument.
Sorkin divides the film into four titles sections, presumably to give structure to another sprawling narrative. Instead, the divisions reinforce its stop-start rhythm. A discussion of the company’s “Meaningful Social Interaction” (MSI) system, for instance, raised questions for me over how engagement-driven systems can amplify political decision and conspiracy theories. But, just beginning to consider these implications, the film distracted me, jumping forward to 2021, where Jeremy Strong’s Zuckerberg is preparing to face Congress. It took an age to get-to-the-point.
His crisis communications team is interrupted by the release of The Facebook Files and the events of the US Capitol riot on January 6th, 2021.
Facebook’s role in the spread of misinformation and the mobilisation of extremist communities’ forms part of the wiser story surrounding the attack. However, the film’s treatment of this material left me wanting more. It gestures towards a vast and complicated relationship between social media, political polarisation and real-world violence, then moves on before this can be properly explored.
I understand that films require pacing. Not every issue can receive equal attention. Yet compressing such serious questions into brief plot developments makes the film feel like a checklist.
The teen bullying storyline is boxed into one short scene and left largely abandoned. The film could’ve spent more time with the young people behind the statistics. Maybe Sorkin could have montaged the 32% of teen-girls who felt their body-image worsen after interaction with Instagram, but I’m not an Oscar baiting director.
History was on repeat seeing the January 6th riot recreated on the big screen. I’ll note this was impactful, less because of Sorkin’s cinematic edge than because of history itself. We forget this catastrophe happened almost six years ago. It still feels like yesterday. But the questions the scene nodded to about political extremism and the power of online platforms remain unsolved.
Historical material like this is disturbing because it is recognisable. We’ve seen these events unfold. Dissected them in news and argued their causes. What I wanted from The Social Reckoning was not a reminder of what happened, but a better understanding of what’s been done about why these problems persist.
I found myself looking beyond the film, following the continuation of political arguments and public accountability. The film uses years of legislation, litigation and public scrutiny, but despite going into pre-production in 2025, the film fixates its narrative between 2019-2021. How did the industry respond?
I wouldn’t call it revisionist. Sorkin fails to bring a fresh perspective to any evidence presented. The Social Reckoning stinks of desire to top Fincher’s predecessor yet doesn’t do enough to establish proper urgency and what the story means now.
The most impactful part of my evening happened before the movie began.
An advert for The Molly Rose Foundation played before the film, reminding me of the very real stakes of unsafe social media. The foundation had partnered with cinema advertising company Pearl & Dean to bring its message to audiences attending screenings. In the advert, Ian Russel speaks about his daughter Molly, who sadly died aged 14 after being exposed to harmful content online.
His testimony was devastating in its raw, real approach. No elaborate plot. No villain archetypes. No swanky split-screens and cinematography. There was a father and a daughter, and the consequences of a digital environment that failed to protect her.
Suddenly, Sorkin’s treatment of the same issues felt artificial. His film attempts to make technology’s danger tangible through corporate spectacle. The advert confronts audiences with the human cost directly.
The partnership demonstrated a connection between awareness and action that the film struggled to achieve. By donating cinema advertising space, Pearl & Dean helped the foundation reach an audience already primed to think about the influence of social media. The advert gave audiences a reason to case and opportunity to engage.
The story doesn’t end when credits roll.
The Social Reckoning tackles an issue intimately familiar. Its subject deserves attention and its source material deserves serious interaction.
The film’s ambitions exceed its execution. Too many controversies compete for too little screen time. It’s ironic that a film about platforms designed to keep us engages struggles to hold my attention with anything I had not already encountered outside the cinema. Perhaps that is the real reckoning.
We don’t need to be convinced social media is bad, Sorkin’s film just reminds us of the problem. Ian Russell’s testimony reminds us why it matters.





Comments