They Say TV's Too Woke - They're Wrong - It's Nowhere Near Woke Enough

If I was asked to define what has become one of the most aggressively weaponised phrases in the English language, I would call it a willingness, an openness, towards others and different points of view from your own.
According to a YouGov survey published in 2024, only 6% of British people associate ‘woke’ with this definition. One in ten defined it as being oversensitive. 5% branded ‘wokeness’ as ‘brain dead anxiety’. However you look at it, the so-called woke debate is very politically charged, and though everybody seems to love a Bridgerton or an Off Campus, the very best TV is politically charged too. The majority of us have a TV in our homes, like a bed, like a car, like a family member. We listen to it. It has the power to create extraordinary change.
With every fandom that adores a television programme comes a very loud majority who denounce its place in the culture war that this very same loud majority helped create. ‘Woke’ became a shorthand, a ragebait, a way to attract extreme YouTube subscribers or Instagram followers who also adhere to this anti-progress algorithm.
We have seen this reaction to fandoms for Doctor Who (to Yasmin Finney’s trans character Rose Noble), Star Wars (to Kelly Marie Tran’s casting in The Last Jedi), even to Rick and Morty. We have also seen this increasingly in parties. Your bills are going up, your kids are struggling to buy a house - the reform party, the MAGA movement, will blame it on change, on anybody who is different to the target audience of white straight middle-aged males watching. The strongest crutch that Trump, Farage or any of their Cronies seem to have is ‘how woke everything has become’. The word is becoming as grating as the nails-on-a-chalkboard analogy is lazy.
Politics boils down to two things: friends and enemies. The proposition that there are ‘enemies’ is exactly why those alt-right YouTube channels have become so popular: they latch onto an itch, and find somebody to blame for that itch. When there is outrage towards the supposed ‘wokeness’ of a workplace policy, or an institution like the BBC, or a singular TV programme, it can be defined as a moral panic: a fear that change will bring only negative effects. Take, for instance, the quintessentially racist, xenophobic stereotype that all immigrants are rapists. This is an othering, a deviance, based not on statistics, but latching onto a fear, an insecurity, like a tic, until it bleeds out into rage.
These YouTubers and political parties depict themselves as underdogs. They brand the people in charge as gatekeepers constricting their freedom of expression. We see this on outlets that market themselves as a voice for the anti-woke, like GB News and Piers Morgan Uncensored, but conversations also drift onto magazine programmes like Good Morning Britain and This Morning because these panel discussions are easy to book, and they get people talking quite aggressively. That creates hits, comments and engagement, making the brand appear more reputable. Frankly, all this metapolitics just feels like a distraction from actual progress.
In 2024, a complaint from ‘The Campaign for Common Sense’ accused the BBC of ‘peddling a steady diet of woke bias’. Of all the debates circling around the beeb recently, the one about impartiality has undoubtedly become the loudest. However, their response to this particular complaint was well-articulated: "Cherry-picking a handful of examples or highlighting genuine mistakes in thousands of hours of output does not constitute analysis and is not a true representation of BBC content.” Which is true. It remains the case that the vast majority of people you see on the screen are white. Most of them are straight, and cis.
I would argue that in some areas, TV is nowhere near ‘woke’ enough. That is, nowhere near representative enough of some groups. While diversity charters have increasingly managed to improve the visibility, both in front of and behind the camera - of female voices, voices from other countries, races, sexualities, from working class backgrounds - when it comes to, say, asexuality or pansexuality, producers, writers and companies still have a long way to push.
The representation of asexual characters is slightly better now than twenty years ago, but has come nowhere near as far as representation of gay or bisexual characters. In Sex Education, Florence says “I don’t feel anything [about sex], I have no connection to it”, to which Dr Milburn replies “Sex just doesn’t do it for some people. Some asexual people still want romantic relationships. Others don’t want either. Sexuality is fluid. Sex doesn’t make us whole.” In Bojack Horseman, Todd comes out as asexual, and even has two asexual girlfriends over the course of the show, Yolanda and Maude. This has come a long way from the TV show House, which, as with the very old and horrid stigma, equated asexuality to a disability, to a phase a person grows out of. An asexual character has an operation that he is told will increase his sexual urges, which surprises his wife, and which House says has “Course corrected two people’s wildly screwed up world views”.
Even with Todd, one of the few representations the asexual community can be proud of, comes the belief that asexual people can only go out with other asexual people. This is not necessarily true - they can fall in love with allosexual people - although it is very productive to understand that asexuality and aromanticism are now always, or not often, intertwined.
The main reason asexual characters are so rarely represented in fiction is because romance is often positioned as a characters’ main goal. Most stories hinge on a ‘Get the girl’ or a ‘Will they won’t they?’ or an ‘enemies to lovers’ or a ‘man goes on a journey’. Try to think of an exception, and you will struggle. Cinematic language is simply not fluent in any other language. Romance and sex is a storytelling convenience, and a way to give characters personality, and agenda, without finding creative stimuli for either. Even when asexuality characters are put onto screen, shipping culture equally tries to erase it. In Steven Universe, the storyboarders have often cited Peridot as ace, but the fandom constantly try to ship her with other characters. Steven Universe Wiki even introduces her as “a sexually attractive member of the Crystal Gems”.
I can think of only one example - Varys in Game of Thrones - of a character being asexual without it being a massive plot point, an othering, that gets constantly referred to. Sure, we need representation from full stop, but the best way forward is through synthesis and normalisation.
When it comes to pansexuality, only two reasonable representations come to mind. The first of these being Captain Jack Harkness from Doctor Who, but even then, the pansexuality of characters from its spin off, Torchwood, tended to be picked up and dropped at the writers’ convenience. In Sense 8, the hive mind of its lead characters leads to shared experiences between them, including shared sexualities. ‘Sensates’ can occupy bodies of others, and the creators said they think of every character in the show as pansexual. Like with the novel and film ‘Every Day’, where the lead character, as the title implies, wakes up in a different body every single day, this seems to suggest that pansexuality can only be represented if there is a body hopping gimmick at the heart of the narrative.
The writers of the Deadpool comics identified their character as pansexual, but not to suggest this was a valid sexuality, instead noting “he will have sex with anything that moves”.
Fascist, anti-diversity movements and ideologies have crept up on us so quickly that a lot of people have just ignored them. We seem to not be listening to the history curriculums in school anymore - the spread of far-right movements across Europe brings us closer to the events of this time last century than any of us should feel comfortable with - so TV has become the best medium for education, progress and revolution. If only the programmes would just speak a little louder. Then, maybe, finally,




Comments