top of page

A Review and Cultural Commentary of Annie Jacobsen’s ‘Biological War’

2d
4 min read

Readers of Annie Jacobsen’s Sunday Times bestseller non-fiction thriller ‘Biological War: A Scenario’ would have been enthralled by reports emerging from Siberia in early October. A laboratory worker had died from a severe bout of pneumonia, which prompted speculation that they had contracted pneumonic plague through a potential lab exposure. As reports and speculation grew, it seemed as though Jacobsen’s fictional account of a biological plague outbreak had occurred in real life at the exact geographical location she envisioned. 


However, the World Health Organisation (WHO) did clarify that laboratory worker’s cause of death remains unconfirmed, as does the fact of whether this was a plague infection. No other speculative reports of a plague outbreak have been reported in Russia since. This bizarre and seemingly coincidental incident makes revisiting Jacobsen’s non-fiction thriller worthwhile. 


It is poignant to wonder what a pneumonic or other plague outbreak could look like, and whether it could ever evolve into a biological war. What would be the global reaction, and what tools are in place to mitigate this unnerving situation? .


Biological warfare can be defined as the deliberate use of biological agents to cause death and disruption to the human population. Unlike conventional warfare, its consequences are not necessarily confined to one location. A biological agent can create social, economic, and environmental instability, and can cross geographical borders. 


In her book, Jacobsen constructs a scenario in which a highly contagious pneumonic plague accidentally emerges from a Russian laboratory and goes global. Markedly, she draws on a plethora of interviews with individuals with senior governmental, military and medical expertise to examine how a genetically modified plague from a lab can create a biological war. 


The book’s examination of bio-defence: the scientific, medical, institutional and security measures designed to prevent, detect, and respond to biological threats, is historically and scientifically thorough. A contemporary understanding of bio-defence can help in our understanding of international work to mitigate instances of warfare. For example, the World Health Organisation’s (WHO) ‘Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network’, as well as the International Health Regulations (2005) are frameworks for detecting and coordinating immediate and long-term responses to public health emergencies. 


Meanwhile, the 1975 ‘Biological Weapons Convention’, signed by over 180 states, prohibits the development, acquisition and stockpiling of biological and toxin weapons.


But as Jacobsen illustrates, the existence of international agreements does not necessarily eliminate an impending threat. Enforcement, transparency and compliance are persistent challenges, particularly as emerging scientific research can create oversight issues for signatories. The book explores the concept of ‘dual-use technology’, where man-made technology can either help or harm. Weapons of Mass Destruction, known better as WMD are examples of this. States furthering the development of chemical, biological, and military warfare must also take into account the costs and benefits of potential harm. 


One of the more unnerving aspects of the book is the hyper-realistic portrayal of what happens when defensive capabilities and mechanisms fail. Jacobsen succinctly traces the consequences of the pneumonic plague outbreak: delayed detection, overwhelmed hospitals, shortages of essential vaccines, political instability, and the erosion of governmental trust. This account is particularly relevant in a post-COVID-19 landscape; the pandemic exacerbated public distrust with the government, exposed the lack of international co-ordination in its first few months, and created deep scientific uncertainty worldwide with the rise of alternative “anti-vaxx” media online. 


The concern within the book is not limited to the collapse of humanity due to a plague outbreak; it takes into account the fragility of the governmental, scientific, and media institutions in which society is ever-dependent on. 


‘Devolution’ is one of the final concepts explored in the book, and can be defined as the U.S governments’ continuity of authority planning in circumstances where incapacity exists within conventional institutions. Jacobsen describes how authority and essential governmental functions could be transferred to designated personnel and alternative locations, allowing the state to preserve its capacity to operate following an existential crisis. It is important for such contingency plans to exist, as governments must consider ways to ensure continuity within a crisis to preserve public order. 


Nevertheless, the prospect of a government preparing to function in the aftermath of widespread societal collapse is unnerving, particularly in an era where institutions seem less connected to the public they serve. 


Jacobsen’s work has received considerable critical acclaim, although several outlets have criticised its accumulation of worst-case-scenarios to be too narrow in its understanding of biological threats. An easy mistake for readers to make is assuming that a hypothesis can be mistaken for a prediction. In line with this, Jacobsen’s emphasis on catastrophic societal collapse does not leave room for the possibilities of successful intervention, global mediation, and emerging scientific innovation.


Of course, we cannot be certain of the measures states could take to mitigate a global plague outbreak if it did occur, but we can be sure that technological and scientific evolution is promising, given the successful COVID-19 vaccine rollout that mitigated symptoms for those infected. Six years on, scientists are continuing to study the long-term health impacts, with greater global efforts on contingency planning in the event of another outbreak.


Crucially, Jacobsen’s thriller ignited a discussion of the severity of biological warfare, as well as the consequences of potential institutional complacency. The incident in Siberia last month did not confirm the book’s fictional scenario, but it does demonstrate the importance of transparency within laboratories and states. Jacobsen leaves readers wondering whether governments and scientific advancements alike are creating the very threat they deem likely to cause irrevocable harm globally; there is no way to know whether the plethora of biological labs worldwide are covertly working to create deadly viral pathogens to inflict upon certain adversaries. 


By demonstrating to readers what the end result of biological war looks like, Jacobsen emphasises the cruciality of biosafety and biosecurity, as it is the bedrock upon which future generations will depend on it. 

Comments


bottom of page