Films Need an Ending, They Just Don't Always Need to Be a Happy One

We all want a happy ending, to ride off into the sunset having overcome our
obstacles and achieved everything we want to. But that is not real life, and not
everyone gets a happy ending.
In cinema, having this as a narrative, in which the protagonist of a story gets a happy
ending is often the way to go. It offers a structure that is satisfying to the viewer,
seeing someone that you are attached to get everything they desire, and come out of
the experience in a better state than they went into it to.
But, is this always really necessary? We all know that sometimes in life we don't
always get what we want, and to see in a film a character not get a happy ending, or
leave the film not telling the audience the outcome can be more reflective of a true
experience. While this may not be as satisfying, it’s more real, and to me, that can
sometimes be better.
I was recently rewatching Good Will Hunting and The Perks of Being a Wallflower at
Cineworld’s 30th anniversary celebrations when this idea came into my head, and
these are two films that do it so well, but for different reasons.
Good Will Hunting shows us the progression of Will, as he navigates love, loss and
becoming a maths prodigy overnight. Two-thirds into the film, he sends his girlfriend
away due to past trauma, but after overcoming his issues with his therapist, he quite
literally rides into the sunset to get her back.
While this may be seen as a happy ending, in that we have seen Will overcome his
problems, and become a better person, we never actually see the reunion of the
couple. We never know if they made it, did they get back together and were his
issues fully resolved.
The Perks of Being a Wallflower probably demonstrates my point even more. One of
the main final points of the film in which Charlie almost takes his own life is a major
setback in his progress through the film.
He starts out as a loner, then begins to make friends, navigating his first relationship
and break up, has a fight to protect his friend and conquers many of his own
personal battles.
Close to the credit roll, we see the thing Charlie has been chasing all throughout the
film leave him, as Emma Watson’s Sam leaves for College. This starts a spiral for
Charlie that ends up with him being admitted into a mental hospital, having relived
the trauma with his aunt.
Sam comes back to visit Charlie on a college break, but the hero doesn’t get the girl
in this one, and that is overall more satisfying as a story beat to me.
While this is not an experience that everyone will have had exactly, everyone will be
able to relate to it in some way. The awkward stage of high school and figuring out
who you are as a person is littered all throughout the film. We all know what it was
like to have a crush on someone, but never get that person in the end.
This is very similar to Netflix’s Sex Education, the two main characters (Otis and
Maeve) are in an on again, off again situation throughout the series. When we finally
leave the series, the two of them are not together. While at first this is kind of
frustrating, when you sit with it for a while, you realise that it is more like real life and
relatable than if they were to get together in some kind of fairy tale romance.
One final film that does this well is Laika Studios’ Wildwood. By the end of the film,
Prue has achieved everything she set out to do, she saves her baby brother and
defeats the villain. But in the final moments as she rests in her home, she can't help
but feel that while she did the right thing, it doesn't always feel like the right thing.
While she knows that the evil witch of the story was trying to get her son back the
wrong way, Prue knows that she was a grief-stricken mother who would do anything
to reunite with her son. Even though Prue got what she wanted, she still feels as that
the success she got was not without its sacrifices and drawbacks, something we all
can resonate with in some way.
Marvel and superhero cinema are another perfect example of this. Often in a
superhero film, quite often the hero's goal is achieved, but it is not without great
personal expense that leads to an unhappy ending for the main character.
Captain America: The First Avenger shows this, as Steve Rogers saves the world
from the clutches of Hydra, he is forced to dive the plane into the ice, throwing away
any chance of happiness, and trapping him ice for 70 plus years.
Another example of this within the MCU is Spider-Man: No Way Home. Again, in an
attempt to fix his mistake of trying to brain wash the world, Peter Parker has to make
everyone forget he exists, including his girlfriend and best friend.
To achieve what we want and sometimes protect people, we must offer a sacrifice,
this is something we can all relate to (even if it is not as world ending as these
examples).
Having said all of this, there are times when we want to see the hero of a story get
what they want, get the girl or reach the goal. It scratches that itch in the back of your
brain and gives you that sweet release of endorphins that you’re looking for when
you head to a movie theater.
But, to me, there is an undeniable sense of realism to a film that doesn’t always have
a happy, perfect ending. Seeing a person not get what they want is sometimes
cynical, sure, but real. Seeing a perfect ending always can take you out of the
illusion, as you know it would not go that way in real life, and while there is a place
for that, seeing something be more realistic can make you resonate with the story a
whole lot more.





Comments