top of page

The Death of the Queer Club

Nov 4
5 min read

I recently attended an event in an old haunt, one that had always been an explicitly queer space, very open, polyamorous goings-on, thinly veiled suggestions of threesomes. Even furries felt as though they could openly express themselves there. The music and overall vibe there was experimental, exciting and again, queer.


Imagine my surprise then, when upon arriving for an event in this space, I see through the window a bar full of tote-bag-donned, cap-and-overshirt-wearing, performative, men. I of course cannot claim to know their sexuality, but the overall vibe was very straight, looking around there was none of what I mentioned before.


This got me thinking: why? Why is it that every time a space, or concept, or anything exists for marginalised groups, it is taken over and irreversibly reshaped? And then it hit me: it was something I had long been expecting; but hoping to avoid: the dreaded trendy stage of the queer space. In this city, several queer spaces had also succumbed to this, going from a counter-cultural movement in open rebellion against hetero-normative ideas, to then being filled with those very people.


What is the trendy stage of the queer club you ask? It is a death sentence of cultural innovation within a space. It is something that is seemingly fated, as though when the lease is signed there is a clause that means the venue you have come to love for its all quirks is slowly going to be sanitised of that by its new clientele.


In queer spaces, there is always cultural innovation. Artists like SOPHIE pioneered electronic music, hyper-pop, and much more. In the instance of a queer venue, it is that aforementioned openness that allows you to feel like that clip of Jon Hamm dancing, writing your name on the mixed gender bathroom mirror before doing god knows what substances, and still feeling safe.


I really wanted to understand why this was happening, so I did what anyone with a superiority complex and chip on their shoulder would do, I researched. Eventually, I stumbled upon the idea of ‘Cultural Capital’, something that has now become an, albeit misunderstood, buzzword on social media.


So, why does this keep on happening? It isn’t just venues. Fashion, subcultures, language, and more are consistently extracted from minority communities such as the LGBTQ+, black, asian communities. In the sense of the queer space, it is often where culture begins to thrive. For example, electronic music, seen with artists such as Charli XCX finds its roots from queerness with artists such as SOPHIE.


Cultural capital is an idea developed by Pierre Bordeau that describes one of the ways thatpower is transferred and maintained through social class. Things such as art, dance, music etc.


These venues are a breeding ground for cultural capital; that in an age of instant dopamine, people latch on to. We live in a time where everyone wants everything at once, a society of gratification without putting in the work to obtain it. This is particularly egregious and committed by straight white men and women, who often lack the aforementioned cultural capital, and therefore extract it from others.


Now, a very clear distinction to make here is that straight people within a queer venue is not inherently a problem. I’m not saying that at all, especially as a white, performative, bi-sexual man who currently finds himself in a very happy relationship with a woman. I’ve been taken as straight within these spaces. I get it, no-one wants to feel unwelcome, or that they’re intruding on a space. Many if not all of the straight people within these spaces have good

intentions (save for the occasional unicorn couples you see), and are of course not coming in with the intention of killing the venue in any way.


The issue begins when there are more straight people than queer in the queer space. This is an issue you can find in any marginalised group or setting.


But why would a queer person want to go to a space that is allegedly dedicated to them, a reprieve from the stares, the people who fetishise sexualities and identities, and the disdain that comes for many of us in regular bars, clubs and other venues; that is now overrun by the same group of people?


They don’t. I’ve had friends avoid queer spaces because ‘it’s full of straight people’. What kind of oxymoron is that? Especially when you think about the thing that makes all white and straight people uncomfortable: oppression.


For centuries, the LGBTQ+ community was, and still is, marginalised. Pushed out of every space that was made for, and inhabited by straight people. Whether it was a religious excuse, a moral excuse or simply out of hatred for anything different to them; gay people were not allowed to exist and were hated for it. Even when there was acceptance, such as the Weimar Republic, it soon faded.


This created the queer club, starting in the 1700s in London, pubs that had private, discreet rooms for gay men. In France the club Zanzibar opened, cited as the first openly accepting bar of gay men, the aforementioned Weimar Republic saw an explosion of queer cabaret and bars.


Eventually, the queer space as we know it, or at least as I know it, formed in New York in the1970s, a golden age began after the Stonewall uprising. The community shafted from hidingaway in the darks of seedy bars, to loudly declaring themselves as here and proud of it. In both examples, cultural capital was created. For the Weimar republic it was the cabaret, the magazines, the art; for New York it was the music, the birth of the Ballroom scene, leather

subcultures and more were able to exist and thrive because they had a space specifically for them. They would not exist, at least in the same way, in any other setting.


Back to now, when an existing queer space is ‘taken over’ by these straight culture vultures; it’s a gay burning of the Library of Alexandria. The cultural capital created in the space is now gone, or at least, heavily reduced; creating a knock-on effect where a new queer space is found and people flock there, leaving these spaces as empty, desiccated husks of what they were in their prime. And to add insult to injury, the same people who have inadvertently

drained the original venue will latch on to the next one like cultural vampires.


So how do we stop it? You can’t put a ban on straight people attending these events, and the money they give is a huge plus for the venues. That’s something I cannot answer, smarter minds than my own will have to figure it out. But maybe we should be mean again. As bad as it sounds, part of me wants to be combative, questioning why you, as a straight person with the entire city at your disposal, have chosen to come to a ‘Dykes and Dolls’ night? Queer people, and the culture they create, are at their best when they are allowed to express that freely, I would implore the straight community to recognise that and attempt to create their own version instead of latching onto ours.

Comments


bottom of page